Great ads have a single idea. A single idea makes them memorable. Here’s one car ad with nine too many.
A still from Lincoln’s 2013 ad
Too many ideas are death. In advertising that is. Advertising is about persuasion, and to persuade you need to say something strong and memorable. The temptation with a great product is to rave about all its wonderful features, but the best ads have a single idea that people can recall.
There’s a tennis ball analogy. If someone throws you a load of balls at the same time the chances are you are not going to catch any of them. But if you’re thrown one tennis ball, your chances of catching it increase. It’s the same in communications and advertising. One idea is easier to remember.
In the advertising world this is called the ‘single minded proposition’. I call it the single idea.
How many ideas in this ad?
The Lincoln Motor Company is much-maligned for its terrible ads. This ad illustrates the problem of too many ideas.
Let’s look at the copy. (You can hover over the underlined text to see a breakdown)
This is about moving forward by looking back
and 90 years of doing what others have not.
It’s about open-mindedness to the way things open
And setting precedence for presidents.
It’s shifting the concept of shifting
It’s about finding inspiration in the unexpected
And people of means who have found meaning in it
This is about marching to the beat of a different drum
And being an audiophile’s dream within a dream
This is about making genius look simple
And making noise by being quiet
It’s about big ideas with smaller footprints
And seeing more of the world because there is so much world to see
This is about going places others aren’t
Introducing the Lincoln Motor Company.
The ad is beautifully shot. It looks stunning. The sound track: amazing. Nicely edited. But that’s a lot of tennis balls to throw at the viewer. I counted ten.
When ads are tested participants are asked a variety of questions. One question is: “what is the ad trying to say?” The ideal response from participants should be same and match the intention of the ad. Another question asked is: “what do you remember most?” Again, one answer from participants is ideal.
A uniform response is unlikely with an ad like this. Ten people could give ten different answers.
The advertising company and/or the client seems to think that if they show all the great features of the car people will be compelled to buy it. They have succeeded in showing some great features but it’s all very forgettable. The thing I remember most is Abraham Lincoln in the fog. Not going to make me buy the car.
An ad with a single idea
This is how it should be done:
It’s a brave ad. They took a risk by being honest about the product’s weakness. But by doing that they have used contrast to emphasise its core strength. It’s clever, clear and memorable. And it will no doubt persuade people that it’s the right car for them.
That’s the power of a single idea.
I love the tennis ball analogy. Interesting breakdown of the Lincoln ad. I counted 11 ideas. It strikes me very strange that an ad like that would make it through testing. I wouldn’t be surprised if they didn’t test it.
The second ad is hilarious.
The second ad is pretty funny. I’ve watched it probably 20-30 times – never gets boring.
Just out of interest – what idea do you think I missed?
The line about marching to the beat of a different drum. I think the are trying to say they are doing things differently and not just a regular car company.